There is a potential tension here between the granularity of ‘scene types’ and the utility of the broad-brush approach. Personally, I’d go with the latter because a more generic ‘mechanic’ is easier to grok and apply from situation to situation, rather than having tables fret about ‘what type of scene is this?’ and applying the relevant considerations. But my view is probably not hugely useful because I’m not your target audience here and those who want to understand the ‘how’ of it might well appreciate more ‘guardrails’.
There is a potential tension here between the granularity of ‘scene types’ and the utility of the broad-brush approach. Personally, I’d go with the latter because a more generic ‘mechanic’ is easier to grok and apply from situation to situation, rather than having tables fret about ‘what type of scene is this?’ and applying the relevant considerations. But my view is probably not hugely useful because I’m not your target audience here and those who want to understand the ‘how’ of it might well appreciate more ‘guardrails’.